29 December 2006

Transactional Memory: Panacea or Confounder?

There is a very nice review article on the subject of transactional memory (TM) as applied to programming languages in ACM Queue, Vol. 4 No. 10. The article does a reasonable job of describing the basics of transaction processing, and describes how these techniques could be used to directly expose transaction semantics as a built-in programming language feature.

Transaction processing has been actively researched by the databases community since well before my time, probably for 30+ years. This is important, because it means that the really new ideas embodied by TM are limited to approximately the following:
  • Transactions can be exposed as a general purpose language construct (not just in database languages).
  • Hardware can be modified to reduce TM overhead.
These ideas are interesting enough, and certainly warrant research. However, there are some basic compromises that transactions require, and nothing about TM changes that.

There is a fundamental difference of approach when writing code that uses synchronization primitives (mutexes, condition variables, etc.) for deadlock/livelock-free algorithms, versus transaction processing. For the former, we specifically write code that will always make forward progress, while trying to limit the synchronization overhead. With transactions, we are working at a much higher level, and leave it to the transaction manager to detect when conflicts arise, then (hopefully) make progress even when transactions conflict.

So, I think TM is both panacea and confounder:
  • Panacea: Programmers can work at a higher level that doesn't require thinking as hard about parallel execution.
  • Confounder: When working with transactions instead of low level synchronization, there is a lack of detailed information that prevents achieving maximum performance for many applications.
TM may be the right tool for some programming jobs, but it is almost certainly not the right tool for all programming jobs.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home